- This topic has 32 replies, 15 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 6 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
Is it appropriate to charge my son rent. He lives at home 24yr old and has a good job.
inapropriate
I charge all of my kids rent. Most don’t have good jobs – for example, the two year old – but it’s all written down, and when they do get jobs, I’ll give them the bill.
From the time I started working full time until the time I moved out, I paid rent. After I moved out, my dad z”l gave it back to me, explaining that he had put it aside, but they hadn’t needed it for anything.
Insane and inappropriate with also being a lack of love for your child
Clearly there is more to the story than “he is 24, works and lives at home”.
No.
if they would have charged me when I was living by them I should charge them now for living by me.
Clearly there is more to the story than “he is 24, works and lives at home”.
Why?
The son should know on his own to help out paying for household and food expenses.
There is nothing wrong with asking him to pay what he can afford for his upkeep.
It makes more sense for him to move out than to pay his parents rent.
It depends what your goal is:
Do you want to get him out of the house? Than yes
Do you want to teach him life skills? Than tahkamamash dad mayne had the right idea
But if youre just doing it cuz youre bored than there are other ways to fill your time
When i was an adult living in my parents home i did not pay rent but i did pay certain household bills every month.
Working adult children shouldn’t be freeloaders.
same goes for learning children eh Joseph?
So what you think is right
The tremendous schar earned from their Limud Torah is shared by their parents.
How much do people charge their married kids to come for a Shabbos?
The schar from other mitzvos don’t?
DY. That’s having guest it’s different.
So of course charge them less, but still, how much?
Charge the same amount you charge your other guest don’t discriminate.
It makes sense for him to contribute toward household expenses, but does not make sense for parents to charge rent.
RebYidd: What if the parents can’t afford to house him?
Then he can contribute toward household expenses as a member of the household.
Is it wrong for parents in that desperate situation to charge rent?
If its really not a burden them there is chesed to be done here…
Probably not a great idea, even if you are in a bad matzav financially. Sit him down and say honey heres how its going to work: we are providing you a room meals snacks soap shampoo etc.. You are responsible for a good attitude,your own clothes and your entertainment budget, Also as part of a household occasionally sweep a floor, change a diaper[if applicable] or offer to run an errand
“Why”?
Because typically parents dont charge their children to live in their home. You think the parents woke up one day and said, ok, he turned 24, he can support himself, lets charge him rent.
And a working alte bochor living with and eating by mommy and totti at age 40 you’d say the same or what is your age cutoff?
If he’s too young to be renting, he’s too young. If he’s old enough, he should rent from someone other than his parents.
My father charged me rent when I started working and I resented it, but I don’t charge my single children who are working and living at home. Maybe my father needed the money; I don’t. Still the charging me rent was an impetus for me to move out on my own. I was old enough and it was the best move for me at the time. I agree, children should feel on their own to contribute in some way, but really, if they are just starting out, i would prefer they save their money for a time when they marry and need money to set up a household.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.