Comments on: AUDIO: Michael Savege Slams Metzitzah B’Peh And Orthodox Jews

By: realistchareidi

realistchareidi — Wed, 10 Apr 2013 11:08:17 +0000

When this all started about 7 or 8 years ago we had rabbi zimmerman speak to my night kollel on the subject. One of the things he said is that rav shlomo zalman aurbach ztzl told him that using a tube and suction from the mouth was 100% considered metzizah BPeh. When r zimmerman asked him why he didn’t publicize his psak he stated “I’m an old man and don’t want people to break my windows”. This shows that some hard line metzizah bpeh supporters are blinded by minhag and refuse to listen to psak especially if it can protect these rare cases while still keeping the minhag.

By: geula

geula — Wed, 10 Apr 2013 11:05:32 +0000

There’s a reason why England Banned him from entering; he is an inciter, a hater and that can cause danger.

By: mark levin

mark levin — Wed, 10 Apr 2013 04:54:31 +0000

34 (nfgo3),

because thats the m’sorah! you libs are always treading all over the tradition.

the other reason “MAY” be that the suction is better BP than with an intermediary.

there is NO reason anyone including herr bloomberg should be treading on bris mila and its about time all the MBP deniers out there realize this is FAAAAAAAAR BIIIIIIGGGGERRRRR than just MBP. Today its MBP and tomorrow its the whole thing.

By: Git Meshige

Git Meshige — Wed, 10 Apr 2013 00:35:12 +0000

Anyone that changes their G-D given name, Weiner, to a farshtinkine name like Savage, needs no explanation as to what their agenda is. Michael Weiner is a Jew that is a wannabe Christian. His mother is a Jew and that makes him a Jew, no matter what he says. He hates Torah Shebal Peh with the same vitriol his Christian counterparts do. Its a shame he was not around at the time of the Holocaust because he would have been rounded up with all the Orthodox he so despises. But he will get his fair share in the world to come and he will face the truth sooner rather than later. Hope he either gets off the air or peigers quickly

By: geula

geula — Tue, 09 Apr 2013 23:53:57 +0000

sam the man.
You wouldnt only be considered an am haaretz dummy or a shame for humanity by any descent normal yid. But try to speak these few words to any respectful goy and you would understand and finally learn how a brain unpolished becomes a brain tarnished. I have no idea what you’re doing commenting on a yeshivish site. I always wonder why, haters like you still have an interest in people like us. Perhaps you don’t find your place commenting on secular issues and get bullied for your transparent brainless comments; cus no matter frum or not. A brain and character remains the same. And those are two factors you must have to survive the outside world too. I suggest you begin working on your midos and start respecting and understanding things that even my christian neighbor understand. otherwise you’ll loose both worlds.

By: Git Meshige

Git Meshige — Tue, 09 Apr 2013 23:45:56 +0000

Peakman, about 6 years ago he called the Sanhedrin, arrogant. Look it up . He hates the talmud, he hates Torah Shebal peh. He claims he loves G-D. Muslims and radicals also love G-D, but are they right?

By: geula

geula — Tue, 09 Apr 2013 23:44:45 +0000

jewish source:
I’m really happy for you that you know exactly what would solve the problems of this generations. Even the gedolei hador have had a hard time figuring that out. In regards to “He is not dangerous” He is indeed. I’ve listened to him speak, he has no boundaries and while you may think his ramblings are deep or insightful, it’s just entertaining and sensational to listen to. He uses the shock factor to get his audience to listen and has a funny way of expressing that. In regards to any inyan in halacha and to chilukei dayos. Mr. Savage is a man of his own opinion and surely doesn’t understand the meaning of eilu v’eilu. And if you disagree with the fact that there isn’t only one opinion and that in this case he is wrong then you too are a huge am haaretz. No man can tell another that there is one answer to questions in the torah unless if it’s a chok. And by you saying that answers must be given and implying that Mr. Savages answer is the one then you’re point of not giving answers to kids becomes even more contradicted by urself. Because giving only one way as an answer is worse than any answer.

By: Ani Tapuach

Ani Tapuach — Tue, 09 Apr 2013 22:52:20 +0000

Which is why i listen to Mike Fransesa on the FAN. His passion about sports and his amkus into it inspire me to do the same about Yiddishkeit

By: peakman

peakman — Tue, 09 Apr 2013 21:48:37 +0000

nfgo3

good question as amatter of fact the talmuld never says B’Peh nor does the rambam just Metzitzah

By: nfgo3

nfgo3 — Tue, 09 Apr 2013 20:14:03 +0000

My limited understanding of MB’p is that it is done for medical reasons, to promote blood flow and thereby reduce the risk of infection; it is not commanded by halacha. If that is correct, then there could be better ways to accomplish what MB’p is intended to do, by using a medically sterile mechanical suction device to accomplish what the mohel is now doing with his mouth. Can anyone explain why a sterile mechanical device cannot be substituted for a mohel’s mouth?