Seeing Red, Ticketed Drivers Sue NYC Over Brief Yellow Lights

(Thursday, December 6th, 2012)

Three drivers nabbed by New York City cameras monitoring traffic violations have filed suit challenging their tickets, claiming the city’s yellow traffic signals are rigged to turn red too quickly.

The putative class action, filed Wednesday in Manhattan Supreme Court, asserts the yellow lights lasted less than three seconds, the minimum time permitted under federal guidelines.

The lawsuit seeks class action status for the “thousands, if not hundreds of thousands” of drivers who have received citations after being caught running red lights on camera. The city has collected $235 million from more than 300 red light cameras since 2007, the lawsuit says.

The American Automobile Association and the New York Post recently examined four random intersections and found the yellow lights lasted less than three seconds, according to the lawsuit.

But the city checked those traffic signals and found the lights had “appropriate yellow signal timing,” said Seth Solomonow, a spokesman for the city’s transportation department. Two of the intersections do not even have cameras, he said.

Morever, he said the city only has 150 traffic cameras, less than half what the lawsuit claims.

“While attorneys haven’t had time to fully review the suit, it appears to be based on the same untrue allegations that were investigated and debunked months ago,” Solomonow said.

The lawsuit seeks restitution for the traffic tickets issued to drivers using the camera system plus an order that the city shut down the cameras until the yellow traffic signals last at least three seconds.

(Reuters)


2 Comments

  1. YakovL says:

    i also think that in some streets like NYC West side where one drives a little faster, there is not enough time to stop even in 3 seconds. If there would be a count down of how many seconds are left while the green line is on (as many places on Ocean Parkway, Brooklyn)then even one second of yellow would be enough.
    Hoping someone can bring this comment to the attorneys/court…

  2. Milhouse says:

    In other cities the companies that operate the cameras have been caught deliberately reducing the yellow light’s duration so as to increase their revenue from red light tickets.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Subscribe to RSS Feed For This Article