I understand what you are saying, but as I live in Emanuel, it is impossible to shelter the children like that – 43 fathers all leaving at once makes a huge impression in such a small place. Several of these men are teachers in the Chassidic school. You can use your idea for isolated incidents, but not one on such a large scale which affects a community so broadly.

She was not prosecuted because she was chareidi. She was prosecuted b/c there were witnesses and a VIDEO to the abuse she commited.. Chareidim are not all Tzaddikim and there are quite a few who dress the part but are in NO WAY chareidi on this inside..
This case is NOTHING like that one.. I for one am looking into sending my daughter to a less funded BY so that the state can’t have control over my daughter’s chinuch.
The lesson to learn here is to have more Private schooling so that we can control the chinuch of our kids.

It’s like letting a nut case control your child’s chinuch!!!

Emanuel is physically and psychologically far away for many Israelis. An unlikely place to visit or explore, it was an easy target to lie about.

Yeah, I know you’ve forgotten already, but this poor mother, an upbeat and gentle woman whom I had the pleasure (and heartache) to meet several times in house arrest, has not. She has been cut off from her children by this Sdomer court for the next five years for the sole crime of realizing that the doctors are using her child as a guinea pig.

Who knows, perhaps if everyone would have come out in defense of this needlessly and heartlessly torn family it wouldn’t have come to this.

Same goes for the Valles case, where the father was dragged through the mud in order to prevent him from pointing his finger against the doctors who let his child die because it was only a Charedi little scum. This poor avrech “confessed” to a crime he never commited in order to avoid Yenty’s ordeal. Yenty stood strong, refusing to “confess”, and now she is paying the price. She is paralyzed from her waist down from the Epidural she received during the birth of her youngest child (perhaps by evil design, nothing is above those monsters), and she had to fight for her right to go for therapy because the doctors said she must be pretending(!) to be paralyzed. This is only a drop in the bucket of pain and abuse that this woman is going through.

The Chofetz Chaim said Communism was a punishment for not standing up with mesiras nefesh against the gezairah of the Cantonists. Will we be able to say ידינו לא שפכו את הדם הזה? Everyone who gave a hand, or even the benefit of the doubt, to these reshaim, will have to come face to face with this מדינה של גיהנם, perhaps through the lens of the Emanuel parsha.

But this is a terrible thing to happen. How could any judge do it?