Regarding the actua point of Rabbi Meiselmann’s work.
Rabbi Meiselmann makes it abundantly clear that the real point of his work (which is really obvious to anyone who read’s it) is to examine whether or not the position’s that Slifkin takes are in fact one’s that were considered “accepted” or not.
And to that end Rabbi MEiselmann does an unbelievable job of demonstrating that they were never accepted, and were roundly condemned.
Could he have done more?
He himself admit’s as much, but the book was already 900 pages how much longer should it be?