Reply To: Romantic songs

I think you miss my point. Certainly it is only an issue between a man and woman who are in a romantic relationship. But that does not mean that any affection is assur.

There is a continuum of affection that starts as innocuously as appearing in public together, and goes all the way up to things that nobody thinks should be done in public.

It appears you want to get rid of all gray areas, and classify every action as either “affection” or “nonaffection”. That’s nuts.