Reply To: How would you respond to Savage on Metzitzah

Perhaps we sould NOT use pesukim to learn halacha?

In a vaccuum? Absolutely not! (and you know that, so I’m surprised at you)

In case you’re going to be really stubborn about this, I’ll point out two things (there are more):

1) Those who require MBP also learned Chumash.

2) MBP doesn’t have to be performed by the mohel, it can be someone else.