The very claim that there is a mesorah here is illogical. The fact that something was done or not done doesn’t make it “The Mesorah”. In the concentration camps people were forced to work on shabbos. Does that make it that now the Mesorah is to not keep shabbos? Obviously not. Something done under duress is simply something done under duress. It is unfortunate that sometimes we don’t have the ability to keep the entire Torah. But how could you even suggest that that creates a mesorah to not keep the Torah?!
Again, you are inventing you own havanah in Mesorahs to justify including Mesorah as relevant “illogical”. I never presented any parameters of what makes something a part of a Mesorah. The fact that something was done or not done doesn’t make it “The Mesorah”. You have no basis whatsoever for such a statement.
The truth is, sometimes that is true and sometimes it’s not. I don’t claim to know or understand the parameters of when it’s one or the other, though.
Furthermore, I never claimed anything specific to “THE mesorah”.