MW13:
Whilst I agree with you that this thread should not concern itself with individual’s actions in the way Yekke2 did, he was justified in doing so, seeing as the individual he was responding to had bought their own actions into the frame on their own volition. They had bought up their own case as being an example of perfectly justifiable behaviour, and when it was pointed out that they had refused to properly defend their actions, the same actions they believed were perfectly fine, it is only fair that YK2 could point out this discrepancy in the manner that he did, observing that they have thus far avoided any and all pertinent points short of denying daas Torah.