Reply To: Would I be Jewish ? Some orthodox say yes some no

Home Forums Controversial Topics Would I be Jewish ? Some orthodox say yes some no Reply To: Would I be Jewish ? Some orthodox say yes some no

#1077283
Joseph
Participant

Another relevant question is are you living an Orthodox Jewish observant life today?

It is also notable that the Conservative movement has been outside of acceptable Jewish practice far longer than you assume. At least as far back as in the early 1950s there are formal rulings (by such as the preeminent Orthodox legal decisor Rabbi Moshe Feinstein among others) that the Conservatives are not considered to be practicing Judaism and is considered heretical. Indeed that would be the case from before the ’50s as well.