“So long as you know better than the gedolei hador who were actually there,”
What gedolei hador who were actually there?
“You can determine the veracity, or lack thereof, merely by the “sound” of it!”
No, and neither can you. But when something sounds fishy we suspect it, and I’m not basing my hashkafah on some mayseh.
And, Joe, before you start mouthing off about how Rav Kanievsky thinks that book is the greatest thing since sliced bread, I think you ought to have a look at page 3 (in the hebrewbooks pagination). Rav Kanievsky made the author put in a disclaimer saying that there’s material in the book whose veracity is unknown and, therefore,
“?? ????? ????? ?????? ??? ?????”