“Pashtus of the Gemara is actually that Moshe Rabbeinu did get an answer, ???? ???? ????? ????? ????. The Gemara then says that Rebbi Meir holds that for ??? ???? ?? there is not always a reason.”
I wasn’t discussing the answer; I was discussing the question.
“that is not the primary function of Toras Hagilgul in the Arizal.”
It doesn’t have to be the primary function. As long as it answers the issue, my point is that anyone who was bothered by this issue obviously didn’t hold of, or didn’t know about gilgul.