Reply To: Suffering Due to Previous Gilgul

“I really have to doubt your sincerity in even starting this thread.”

I’m sorry you feel that way. I did bring it to my Rabbi and thought it would be nice to talk about it with other people also. I only have the best of intentions.

I never called anything childish or vengeful. You said those words. I am calling it true, false or unknowable; and the practical ramifications of calling it true.

“The shiur is on a topic that is obviously not easily understood and not for everyone.”

It’s public on youtube and is basically titled “if you want to know about this- click here.”

“Your portrayal of a neshamas past nisyonos to be a reason to treat a person differently in this life is even more astounding. Even ridiculous. How do people make such a leap?!”

I dont understand what you dont understand. It’s human nature to treat formal criminals different than innocent victims. You really don’t understand how it could effect someones life who is blind from birth if all of society views him as having committed a grave sin in a previous life?