apushatayid: This conversation started with your incorrect comment of “Acording to Rav Moshe Z’l there is no such thing as Chalav Stam. There is Chalav Akum and Chalav Yisroel.” I simply pointed out that Rav Moshe certainly does differentiate between C”S (which he calls CH”C) and real C”Y, i.e. that was witnessed by a real Yisroel. And I pointed out this is obvious since Rav Moshe explicity paskens that a baal nefesh should not consume C”S/CH”C and only consume real C”Y. If there were no difference, as you claimed “Acording to Rav Moshe Z’l there is no such thing as Chalav Stam”, then there would be no way for Rav Moshe to instruct those who are a baal nefesh to refrain from C”S.
Menu