Reply To: Kashas on the Parsha

Home Forums Bais Medrash Kashas on the Parsha Reply To: Kashas on the Parsha

#1169303
Chortkov
Participant

Yekke, your last post is obviously the basic answer, especially since we can say that in Chutz La’aretz he didn’t do Kedushin, as the Ramban writes regarding all other Mitzvos.

I am not sure if you understood what i wrote fully; I don’t think i explained myself correctly.

Kiddushin is a Chiddush Hatorah – i don’t mean they didn’t KEEP that law, i mean that Kiddushin before Har Sinai doesn’t work (The Rambam says that before Matan Torah there was Nissuin only and no Kiddushin; Kiddushin can only happen after Matan Torah) – therefore the Avos were not going against the Torah at all by not doing Kiddushin