Reply To: Kashas on the Parsha

since we started the torah again i wanted to pose a kasha to the cr oilam (ive asked this to people and havent got an answer)

Hashem told Adam “because you listened to your wife the earth will be cursed…” this shows the sin was “listening to his wife” and not “eating from the eitz hadas”, the ohr HaChaim states that adam sinned b’oneis because he didnt know it was from the eitz hadas (im paraphrasing, you can look it up yourself) if thats the case why was he punished

please dont say he wasnt, the earth was, (like the ohr hachaim does) because “bzayas apecha” goes on even things that didnt have to do with the earth

if im not being clear please say so, and ill try to explain better