IIFT
“So you wish to sell us that for our ancestors Shavuos was primarily a Wheat Festival,Tu B’Av a Festival Of Love, Succos a Harvest Festival,etc.”
what? No where did you get that from?
you dont need me to tell you what they celebrated Open your hcumash it will tell you what why they celebrated Sukkos and Shavuos. Open a gemra taanis it will tell you about Tu B’Av I’m not sure how you got there.
“do you really believe a shift from life revolving around beis hamikdash and karbanos to today is merely “minor sociological details” ‘?
It depends for whom”
Can you elaborate? Or at least tell us if you view your life with a beis hamikdash to without as one that would differ in a “minor sociological detail”
LU
“Even if they are not minor, they still are sociological details that are not connected to Chareidi hashkafa and hence, have nothing to do with this discussion.”
It is a direct response to the silly notion that charedisim is the “default, traditional manner of being frum” charedi Judiasm (like all branches) is VERY different than Judiasm as practiced a millenia ago let alone during the time of chazal not to mention Matan Torah.