Reply To: Let's make YCT teshuvas, by popa

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Let's make YCT teshuvas, by popa Reply To: Let's make YCT teshuvas, by popa

#1218370

In honor of Purim:

Q: Should one get drunk on Purim?

YCTA:

Of course not; it’s frowned upon by society. But here’s a (arguably) halachic excuse:

It can’t be that we have a chiyuv to wipe out the nation Amalek; it isn’t nice. It must be that Amalek is only a metaphor for the selfishness and close-mindedness inside of us, which is what we must wipe out. And if Amalek isn’t real, Haman can’t either be real. So the story of Purim must be only a symbolic metaphor, much like the story of Bireishis. Therefore, we should only get figuratively drunk off the sheer joy of our open-mindedness.

Q: But isn’t getting drunk brought down li’halacha by rov Rishonim and the Shulchan Oruch?

YCTA:

So what?

Anyway, we hold that the halacha will be like Beis Shammai after Moshiach comes because B”S was smarter then B”H. Now that we have the Medinah it is clearly considered the zman of Moshiach, and according to Darwin’s theory of evolution people keep getting smarter, so we’re smarter than the Shulchan Oruch and the Rishonim. Therefore, we can decide what the Halacha is without giving a flying hoot as to what everyone else has paskened over the past thousand years. Zeh klal gadol bi’YCT.