Ok, AViK, now you have explained that your problem was with my statement “should not be advocated as something everyone has to to do as a general rule, and implied that those who don’t/can’t are wrong.”
Note that in your OP you did not write “Do not move to Norfolk! Move to Eretz Yisrael and make a difference, unless you have a valid exemption”. The OP certainly did sound like a general statement for everyone to follow. Now you have clarified what you really meant, but I still disagree with the premise that it is a general rule except for the minority with valid reasons. Living in EY is wonderful and can certainly enhance one’s ruchnius, but there are many decisions that go into someone figuring out where it is best for him/her to fill his tafkid, and this applies for all people.
Menu