“A sheilah had already been asked there.”
And many posters were telling the OP that a sheilah should not have been asked in the first place, and that he should neither listen to the answer nor ask again.
““Im ein daas, havdalah minayin.”
you dont need daas “ask sheilas” you need daas to make a differentiation between when a sheilah is appropriate and when it isnt. Of course it is sometimes appropriate to ask, but it often isnt and knowing that distiction requires daas.”
Correct. And I pointed that out earlier in this thread. My point in my previous post was that while there are some people who tend to err on the side of asking too much, there seem to be many in the CR who tend to err on the other side.
You do have to ask a sheilah before calling the cops on a fellow Jew (with the exception of a case in which someone’s life is in immediate danger , only the police can help, and they must be called right away. which was not the case in that thread).