Reply To: Question I don’t know the answer to :) 🤔

Daas
I’m not sure how your definition of noach fits the Gemara. But even so it doesn’t change the philosophical question.
Let me ratchet it up a little. If we didn’t exist there would be no discomfort, no pain , no trials etc. both physical and spiritual . Our existence is supposedly because Hashem has a need to give. So Hashem s need to give creates the system . The system has pain and consequences involved. We didn’t ask to be created and part of the system. Had we not been created the loss of reward would not be felt. Therefore how can our creation be part of a selfless need to give? Since ultimately many will suffer?