Benignuman: KODY BROWN, MERI BROWN,JANELLE BROWN, CHRISTINE BROWN,ROBYN SULLIVAN v. JEFFREY R. BUHMAN. Case: 2:11CV00652. It overturned Utah’s statue. Eventually the case was mooted since Utah’s AG promised the Federal court that Utah doesn’t enforce the law anyways. See also the additional points I made in my last comment.
Gaon: We go according to the shitta, as stated in S”A, that R”G set an expiration date. But later the rabbonim extended it. Therefore everyone agrees it continued after expiration, even the shittas that tell us there was an expiration date. But in any event this point is mostly academic. It doesn’t change the other points made.