Reply To: This Beer Predicament

FNY: The big deal about this case is that it might be the first time this has happened on such a massive scale. There is nothing controversial or extreme about avoiding chometz that a goy owned over Pesach in general. Why would you be against kashrus agencies publishing warning lists?

If your argument is that your sfeikas should apply in every single case of chometz sheover alav Pesach, don’t you think some Posek would have thought of it within the past 2000 years?