Reply To: Carlebach niggunim

Home Forums Controversial Topics Carlebach niggunim Reply To: Carlebach niggunim

#1518231
benignuman
Participant

Random3X,

Call them a Hartzig Minyan or a Singing Shabbos.

Choppy,

First, the basic issur of negia was done in front of everyone, there is no need to believe allegations. Second, I am not accepting the allegations as certainly true, I am uncertain. But given that uncertainty, I am bothered by affirmative statements of support or celebration of the man.