Shoping
“It was clear before it began that it could only result in a massacre of the Jews in the ghetto.”
your history is backwards.
The decision to liquidate the ghettio was before the uprising.
Its not like the Germans were letting to JEws live in peace minding their own business, when the ungrateful Jews started shooting at them . Again look up the Wannsee conference, note its date.
This is the problem I alluded to earlier in my second comment on this thread . You dont seem to have a solid understanding of the holocaust, and its history (you arent alone) If only the Jews were peaceful and listened then they wouldn’t have been massacred
“it was clear from even before it began that the Warsaw Uprising could not possibly defeat the German Army.”
obviously, though that was never the goal
Shopping
“ubiquitin, isn’t it a mitzvah to serve Hashem bisimcha?”
Is it? Does this apply t oall times? Are yo usupposed to be besimcha on tisha baav? at a funeral?
” Using the siren to commemorate something is a goyishe idea”
Source please. Since you are condemning many religious Jews who announce the start of Shabbos with a siren. You better have a good source
” and many rabbanim hold it to be assur.”
which ones?