chacham
“As far as the discussion of Nignaz. I think it is silly to make believe that Reb Chaim never claimed that the chilazon is nignaz etc. and it is only hearsay. I honestly believe that that is what he holds. But like every area of Halacha, not all poskim have to agree to one opinion”
Thank you so much for saying that. Last year there was a similar discussion (last link in my previous comment) at the end of which I became disheartened, as it became clear that many in the pro-techeiles camp where not driven ” I want to have a discussion with others and hear different opinions ” nor to be mevakesh the emes.
so thank you for the breath of fresh air.
Fake maven
I don’t want to revisit our whole discussion.
I do hope you can explain why resort to blatantly silly arguments. R’ Chaim doesn’t hold its real, nu nu there are machlokisim in klal yisroel. why does it bother yo uso much that this is yet another machlokes, that you are forced to say such blatantly foolish things? Why not say simply. “I don’t know why R’ chaim (and r’ Elyashiv ybbcl”c) ddiont hold of it, you’d have to ask them” ?