Chossid: “If the Rambam paskened it as a halocho it means it applies to every Yid during his lifetime.
Did he ever take that shvuah? He just didn’t sleep those days.”
You used to argue the point, and now you seem to missing quite a few. Let me try to say it very clearly.
The Rambam paskens that someone who makes a shevua that he won’t sleep for three days gets malkus immediately because IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO KEEP THAT SHEVUA and it is therefore a shevuas shov. That therefore means that no Yid can go without sleep for three days. NO YID because if there was the possibility of even the tzaddik hador going three days without sleep, we wouldn’t give any Yid malkus for making that shevua. At the very least we would wait to see if he falls asleep within those three days.
So it makes no difference whether your rebbe made a shevua or not, it is IMPOSSIBLE that over sukkos he did not sleep at all.
“And some how punked…”
I like the look of that word here, but I think you mean “punkt” : }
“…now you bring up that the Rebbe always spoke about the primacy of halacha, but in the past you say straight out that he didn’t respect halacha.”
When did I say that?