Reply To: Is it healthy for yeshiva bochurim to learn from a New Vilna Shas?

Home Forums Controversial Topics Is it healthy for yeshiva bochurim to learn from a New Vilna Shas? Reply To: Is it healthy for yeshiva bochurim to learn from a New Vilna Shas?

#1674884

Define “healthy”. Is it healthy for math students to have calculators? Is it healthy for writers to have spell/grammar-checks? The world keeps evolving and some skills may be weakened while others are strengthened. With the invention of matches, many of us lost the skill of starting a fire by rubbing sticks together – is that unhealthy? Was the printing of “mesoras haShas” unhealthy (cross references each segment of Gemarah with other places it is mentioned)? Today there are seforim on databases with search engines! A rov can search for teshuvas! The market today is flooded with Seforim that are melaket (collect) in halacha. drush, meforshim on chumash…Get with the program. While we make learning easier, it allows for energy to be spent on deeper concepts in the learning.