Neville
It’s not so complicated
Your here spouting ”economists ” understanding that giving to Peter is the same as not taking away from Paul .
You are willing to overlook the very real difference between an economist looking at the economy as a whole and a purely numbers game versus the discussion here that though it may make no difference to the economy but from a human perspective it’s not exactly fair to Peter to give his money to Paul, while leaving money that Peter earned by Peter and not giving it to Paul is much more equitable being as Peter is after all the one who earned it.
You keep taking the position of the economists that it doesn’t make any difference.
So I am simply asking you to put your money where your mouth is
Since you hold that it makes no difference who earned it. It’s all just a question of the monetary pie, semantics if you will, I am very nicely asking you for all your money.
I think it makes a difference but since you don’t so why won’t you give me all your money.
Make believe your the rich one and the government is taking it from you to give to me.
Makes no difference to you cause we don’t look at the human equation.
To me that it makes a difference, it will make a huge difference to you it’s no difference.
It’s a win win
As I said
I’m waiting for your check
Menu