Dear Joseph,
I am not sure of your stance, let me see if I could get that article. Maybe it would clarify what you are trying to say. I do not recall any real proofs against my stance from your sources. Let me double check, I will get back.
Two quick points.
‘Fades away’ was a misquote. I wrote the reverse of the ‘hypothetical does not materialize’.
The Titanic cannot serve as a textbook case. Time was off essence. There is (almost) no triage. Calmly save as many as possible.