Participant
“which? the question for aaq? ”
Yes
“how can a question not make sense? the one I made here?”
no the one there
” how can it possibly not have shaychus.”
It isnt relevent to the discussion there. The discussion there was about welcoming strangers, Calling a sefardic Rabbi chacham or Rav has no relevance to that topic
“AAQ doesn’t owe you anything”
uh…duh? there’s a reason this discussion is not taking place in b”d.
You seem to think he “owes” you a reply.
In fact yo ustarted a new thread to bully him into replying
“not every comment deserves a response”
thanks so much for repeating what I already said.”
you are most welcome. thus your entire thread is pointless.
“having said that, if pointing out someone violates their own preaching is considered silly by aaq then I can’t fathom why”
whut?
“he frequents the coffee room. probably about half the comments boil down to something like this.”
Yep it happens big deal. Don;t let it get you down.
“if that makes you think you got him”
not answering a very simple question with nothing to lose when the answer has a 99.9% chance of showing the preacher’s hypocrisy is as clear an indication as they get that he’s fluff of baloney.”
Fantastic! You win!
And syag agrees, so you MUST be right*
“you certainly didn’t owe me any response so what prompted you to flaunt your stupidity yet again?”
Pure enjoyment! Nothing more nothing less. I dont think I will convince you. I dont think you will acknowledge that you are contradicting your own premise (You said both not every comment deserves a response, AND “silence shows he is full of baloney”, you cant have it both ways
Actually you can, you can have whatever you want. )
* I hardly engage with Syag especialy on politics for this very reason
see here
for my question “In this context what’s the difference between a book and a memoir? ”
No answer to the question
does that mean I “got her”? I sure think so. do I think it shows her hypocrisy? Absolutely.
Do I get all worked up that it is “the worst social crime” and start a thread about it?
No, I showed she was wrong, big deal move on. She doesn’t have to say “Ok you were right”
(Granted the comparisons are not EXACTLY the same, since my question there was directly related to the conversation at hand, yours was not)