Halevai that the combination of Shabbos, kashrus, internet and television would be unusual in our frum, non-MO society!
Does it make sense that you will find a lot of common ground with someone from a similiar background? Sure.
Would many yeshivish boys be uninterested? Certainly.
Are there plenty of types of boys who are open to such a Shidduch, not necessarily because they share this specific background? Absolutely.