“Please tell me how in the world some gedolim can hold others are not gedolim?”
ummm, you did it above. You do it all the time. You have even built a sect who teaches that our gedolim and rebbe’s are just commonfolk, there are, as you put it, “thousands of them. It’s pretty hard to keep track”. Unlike your rebbe… And you don’t chap the problem with that?
“I would be really surprised to hear that gedolim just say that ‘the Lubavitcher Rebbe isn’t a Gadol’ just because they disagree.”
me too. in fact disagreeing with someone has never been a reason to say they aren’t a gadol. it was cute that you worded it that way to give the illusion perhaps that the gedolim were so petty but that was not their tayna.