I wasn’t bashing rabbi Twerski; i was saying that a parsha book written by a psychiatrist, who knew how to learn but was – in his own words – not a daas torah, is not some kind of authoritative source. That has nothing to do with rabbonim like rav avigdor miller.
I was talking more about AAQs recollection of the quote than rabbi Twerski.
I also said that eisav had lost his yerushah when yaakov got the brochos; you haven’t addressed that. He had nothing to do with eretz yisroel. He was eliminated from it.
The only tzad i can see is that according to some shitos, eisav had the din of a yisroel mumar, which would make him have a shaychus to yishuv EY, but it’s hard to say that when there’s a drasha of ki B’yitzchok velo kol yitzchak…
Yishuv EY according to many is to drive out the goyim – of which include bnei eisav!