Reply To: Question of an ignorant, closed-minded Lubavitcher

>>>I can understand your surprise, but it’s the truth.

You write as if I’m “surprised” by this new piece of “info” that your telling me. I am not surprised because I don’t accept your claim.
There is a fundamental difference between the writings of Marcus Leiman and your claims about the Rebbe Rayatz. Marcus Leiman was officially writing fiction (maybe based on historical facts).
However, the Rebbe Rayatz wrote his stories as accurate historical facts passed down to him from sources he relied on.

Obviously, as a Chabad chossid, there is no way I would accept that stories written by one of my holy rebbes are just made up, ח”ו.

Neither would any other Lubavitcher say that. It would be ridiculous for someone to claim that the Rebbe Rayatz made up stories about his holy predecessors (ח”ו) and still call himself a chossid chabad.

I find it hard to trust you that you heard this from Lubavitchers, especially since you contradict yourself:

“all those who are not Lubavichers know that they are unreliable”
“sorry but I am not saying what I heard from anyone else other than Lubavicher chassidim.”

I assumed you didn’t have a rebbe because you seem oblivious to the basic level of respect that any chossid would have for a rebbe of his.
Now that I know the truth, my hope is that you respect your rebbe more than you expect others to respect their’s.