Reply To: The final word on Moshiach from the meisim (hopefully!)

So now everyone has gotten their “concerns” off their chest and was m’hadar to state their opinions on this and apparently related topics.

Please humor me and again read the title and original post.

In short this sefer proves Chazal holds Moshiach can come from the meisim and Rambam didn’t rule against that.

Lubavitch and chasidus aside….

Is there anyone who read the sefer who disagrees with it’s findings?

Is there anyone who doesn’t think Moshiach can come from the meisim?

Personally I think he did a phenomenal job presenting the sources and analyzing the Rashi’s. His chap on the Rambam is a refreshing take on the subject.

Nu?