Reply To: A Chasidus without a present Rebbe

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee A Chasidus without a present Rebbe Reply To: A Chasidus without a present Rebbe

#2259358
yankel berel
Participant

@CT
1] Ramban is in sefer havikuach – part of kisvei haramban
2] you did not answer whether all yidden who do not listen to ‘nevua’ of the leader of habad are hayav mitah byedi shamayim or not [and why]
3] According to your explanation of nevua i. e. every rebbe of habad who gave etsot in gashmiyut is a navi . we should extend that to every rabbi in yahadut who gives etsot in gashmiyut . why only to habad rebbeim ?
so, following your reasoning nevua NEVER stopped in in Jewish History . Every rabbi gave etsot in gashmiyut . this NEVER stopped .
Ela Mai – they gave etsot because it says in AVOT Ch 6 . Kol Halomed Torah LiShma … Nehenin Mimenu Etsa VeToshiya…
Ditto for the Rebeim of Habad .


@Arso

It is mentioned in Tanya . Quite a Mitnagdishe Shtikel I must say …

To the Group

CS promised to be honest
Meanwhile all I see is more of circle painting around the arrows and then claiming to have hit the target.

“To the group”? Are you qwerty613?