Home › Forums › Decaffeinated Coffee › Zionism › Reply To: Zionism
ReflectiveNotes:
One could ask the same about the Eigel: let’s agree what the eigel should never have been made. But once it was made – and look at all the “achdus” and the miracles of the satan making it literally dance in front of them – what is the point of being anti-eigel? What is the alternative (especially given that the erev rav-influenced nationalists murdered Chur – whom Moshe Rabbeinu specifically appointed in his absence – because he spoke against the idol)? Of course, Hashem didn’t agree, and struck dead all those idolaters.
Decades ago, the Satmar Rav wrote that if the Zionists actually cared about Jewish lives, then the Zionists could go to the UN (yes, that UN) and tell them that they want out, and that the UN should figure out a way to keep all the Jews safe there while ending the Zionist nightmare (for Jews). But even if that UN option were no longer true – and nobody can prove that, but even IF it were no longer true – the major point of “anti-Zionism” is to believe in G-d and His Torah and not in idols.
In other words, G-d runs this world and He doesn’t want the Zionist idol and shmad of His children. The Brisker Rav noted that the Zionist State is the greatest achievement of the satan since the eigel. In hindsight of a century of cataclysmic Zionist damage, this is beyond obvious, too. So, the fact that Hashem very much doesn’t want that State is absolutely true, regardless of the illusory power of the Zionists. So, even if there is no practical human alternative at this time, we still are obligated to turn away from idols and to daven to Hashem for a salvation of His choosing in accordance with His Torah, and recognize that He can do anything, including ending Zionism and vastly improving the lives of the Jews there and everywhere – including but not limited to the geulah sheleimah BB”A.
The other related problem is that praying for that idol gives it spiritual power, as our prayers are very powerful. In fact, as the Brisker Rav noted, that’s what caused the idol State to come into being in the first place: because Jews davened for it instead of the geulah. Both he and the Satmar Rav stated that the geulah would have come then, but that they ruined it. The latter writes this in VaYeChi, if memory serves. So, nobody should repeat that mistake. Daven for the geulah, and that Hashem should keep all Jews safe and well always, and never for the idol. It really is that simple.
There’s so much more that could be said on the topic, BE”H, but that should at least be a start.