Reply To: Should America Offer Israelis a Safe Haven?

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Should America Offer Israelis a Safe Haven? Reply To: Should America Offer Israelis a Safe Haven?

#2319525

Are people seriously suggesting that being near people holding up signs supporting terrorists is a more dangerous situation that being near the actual terrorists themselves? Get a grip. I’m sure Joseph is trolling to some degree, but stop rewriting reality. Israel is currently more dangerous than America. That is a statistical reality, not a statement against Zionism or “actual kefira” or whatever. You can be upset or confused by that reality and how it doesn’t shtem with your religious beliefs, but it remains the reality nonetheless.

If you’re mad about what appears to be Chareidi Anti-Zionists running an I-told-you-so victory lap after a tragedy, then just say so. Don’t come back with weird denials of the observable metzius.

“If you believe that Jews should live in Israel, then doesn’t encouraging to leave indicate a lack of bitachon?”

To prove that you don’t even believe you’re own argument, would you suggest that Jews should move to Gaza right now in its current state? How about the parts of neighboring Islamist dictatorships that are halachically part of Eretz Yisroel? If you claim that that would be reckless and dangerous/pikuach nefesh, isn’t that also just a lack of bitachon by your shittah?