Reply To: I Guess I’m Pulling for the “Chabad Media” Now?

“Nope, I dont care if you believe that Yaacov’s guf is alive.”
You misunderstood the statement you quoted by me. I didn’t say you were insisting on us believing your shittah. I said you were insisting on your shittah fitting perfectly with Rashi (i.e. you’re extremely unwilling to say that you disagree with Rashi; there’s nothing wrong with this. It wasn’t a criticism of you).

“That is an absolutely ridiculous thing to say.”
How? If meforshim say that Rashi means it literally, and your guy says not, then he’s rejecting those meforshim. I don’t understand the issue here. Is it the word “rejecting” that’s bothering you? Should I use a different word?

“You are rejecting the meforshim that say that Yaacov is alive spiritually.”
OK. So?

“Since i highly doubt you bothered reading the meforshim that were discussed on the 2 threads”
When did I ever pretend that I did? I’ve basically just been giving you social advice. I don’t think I’ve ever gotten involved in the lomdush side of this whole shmooze.