rabbiofberlin
If what you are looking for is a consensus, clearly the consensus of the rabbonim is that the eiruv is passul, an opinion which is held by the gedolai hador as well as the leading rabbonim in flatbush – which included the fierce opposition of R’ Avigdor Miller Ztz”l R’ Shmuel Birenbaum Ztz”l and 98% of all local rabbonim.
As a matter of fact the only Rov who actually had the gall to go against all the rabbonim past & present to put up the Eiruv doesn’t even live in Brooklyn.
Once again, I’m not saying each person can’t rely on his rav as an individual, but how can you say wrong, wrong, wrong?