Reply To: Rubah Dlesah Lekaman

charlie brown:

The Shmaytza is bringing a Rayah from the gemorah of the camels that Shmuel doesn’t hold of Rov by mammon in any case. We see according to Shmuel in the Maskana that the case is not dealing with a rov, rather with “Gufo Muchzak”, which (seemingly) is a chezkas haguf that this camel is the one that damaged.

Tosfos in Sanhedrin, which holds Shmuel does hold of rov by mammon in certain cases, would hold our case is also a rov, but a stronger one due to it being in Tevah.

I specificly do not want to get into the rov vs. karov issue.

Thank you to all those who post here.

I am surprised by the lack of other posters on this thread. In a “yeshivish” site, does nobody want to discuss a Gemorah?