Reply To: Mothers Day: Yes, Or No?

Home Forums Bais Medrash Mothers Day: Yes, Or No? Reply To: Mothers Day: Yes, Or No?

#684455
WolfishMusings
Participant

Lo bashamayim hi – once the Torah was revealed, there will be no further revelation? What are you getting at? You are saying, in so many words, Chazal can be wrong in halacha. This is patently incorrect.

In other words, HKBH could determine the halacha one way, but if Chazal decide otherwise, then we follow them. The famous case is the oven of Achnai.

Where have I ever said individual members of Chazal aren’t infallible?

Again, open up a Gemara. The fact that the Gemara says about any Amora’s position “Tiyuvta d’…” proves that that person was not infallible.

The Wolf