Mod 80 words: i very strongly disagree with you that that Halachah is wrong but we say shehakol to listen to the Gedolim even though they are wrong.
the correct Halachah is shehakol, regardless of the reason, Minhag or whatever, that IS the Halachah because the Poskim tell us that is what we are to do. “
That’s playing semantics. You say that i say to listen to our gedolim. then you say to listen to the poskim. ummm isn’t that the same? You also agree that the brocho reasoning for ho’etz is correct while saying a shehakol. I said the same. So I’m not really sure how you don’t agree with me.
And Squeak is correct. Tropicana at best isn’t a single orange orange juice. You can only get that if the oranges came from one single orcahrd. Since any single serving of Tropicana can easily be a mixture of several orchards, its highly unlikely to get a real single single. Which leaves us to drink single malt scotch.