Myfriend, Chasam Sofer said his opinion in a certain place, during a certain period. Applying it under different circumstances may backfire. Rav Hirsh ztz”l used a different approach in Germany, and saved tens of thousands of Yidden from going off the derech. Had the Chasam Sofer’s opinion been used there, almost all of them would have ended up off the derech. Guaranteed.
Menu