popa_bar_abba,
You keep saying cute/annoying things without any real attempt to bring proofs to your side. Sounds like you just want to be right but don’t want to bother with the actual argument.
His Royal Highness,
Just as a side point but do you realize that anyone sitting in his car or bus/train can’t be counted since they are in their own reshus.
shmooze1,
And what if i told you that overpass train tracks can be considered as an eruv? (i dont know if it’s actually utilized im just saying)
I think the biggest problem with this issue is that people are very closed minded and are afraid of what others might think. I wanted to sit and learn the halachos of eruv inside but the Rav informed me that no matter what we come out with he will still not allow me to carry. And every issue he explained to me sounded like he was biased towards eruv being a problem and then someone else explained to me the same halachos from a different perspective so it sounded like it’s not problem.
I dont know who is right or who is wrong but i think if there are in fact good mechitzos around brooklyn then it makes a big difference in this argument.