Reply To: Boro Park Eruv

Home Forums Shabbos! Boro Park Eruv Reply To: Boro Park Eruv

#761149
popa_bar_abba
Participant

popa_bar_abba,

You keep saying cute/annoying things without any real attempt to bring proofs to your side. Sounds like you just want to be right but don’t want to bother with the actual argument.

Precisely. I do not think I am remotely qualified to decide this issue, or contribute meaningfully to whatever is the machlokes between Rav Moshe and the matirim.

I therefore follow Rav Moshe, since he was far greater, and his psak has been accepted by the vast majority of rabbonim, poskim, and roshei yeshiva.

The fact that many of them are also unfamiliar with the issue only bolsters my argument, since it shows that my approach (of just following the greater posek who has been accepted) is correct.

I wanted to sit and learn the halachos of eruv inside but the Rav informed me that no matter what we come out with he will still not allow me to carry.

I wanted to learn how to make a submarine, but my wife told me that no matter what I make, she will not let me use it.