There’s a famous story of 2 rabbonim who paskened differently on the status of a chicken.
Both were unknowingly served the same chicken.
Hashem saw to it that the rav who felt it was treif was unable to eat it; the chicken just kept slipping off his utensil.
The other rav had no problem.
“elu v’elu”
and “shivim panim la’Torah”
Torah lo bashamayim hee, & it depends how your rav holds