Reply To: Worms In Fish

Home Forums Kashruth Worms In Fish Reply To: Worms In Fish

#771378
hello99
Participant

Regardless of the issue of ????, you are claiming a blanket rule that a worm gets the host’s status without bringing any proof outside of ??? ??? ???. How do you know this is not specific. When the ???? lists the issurim involved in eating a bug it does not mention ???? ??? ?????? which would apply to a worm from grapes.

“As I’ve said, Rav Feivel is ????? on 30”

I still find it hard to believe that Rav Feivel’s ????? is 1/10 of Rav Vaye’s. Is this psak from Rav Feivel written somewhere?

“I gave you the example of human hair to show you that it’s intuitively correct”

The proof from hair would only be relevant if we knew that a 17 micron hair was visible at 53 microns in length, because then it would have the same surface area of a 30 micron square. I don’t think this is likely.

“BTW, R’ Belsky’s 1-2mm was the length, (it is thinner than that) which is why what he’s saying is not ridiculous”

We’re talking about length, so what’s the ??????

“In other words, wheras I would not have such a problem making the ?????, one who says that SG is “a concept alien to ??”?” would be caught in a ??? ????.”

The bottom line is you are admitting there is NO ???? ?????? to your ????? ???.