Reply To: Cholov Akum

Home Forums Kashruth Cholov Akum Reply To: Cholov Akum

#772792
MDG
Participant

I don’t think I would call me that.

BUT, I am concerned about people violating their nedarim. From what I understand, a broken vow carries with it a strict punishment from above. Rav Moshe said that if one specifically chooses Chalav Yisrael over Chalav companies three times, then that creates a Neder, vow, through their actions.

I’d rather have people drink Chalav Companies w/o breaking vows, than try Chalav Yisrael for a short while and violate a neder many times.

I guess my point is this: If you want to try C”Y then start by saying Bli Neder. Otherwise don’t start, or know what you are committing to and stick to it (or be matir neder).